(719) 210-8699

Claimant

The person or entity who files an insurance claim seeking compensation for covered damage — in roof insurance claims, the homeowner who has experienced storm damage and is requesting that their insurance company fulfill the policy’s coverage obligations.

← Back to Glossary

Table of Contents

Who Can Be a Claimant

Primary Claimants

The named insured — the person or persons listed on the insurance policy — is the primary claimant with a direct contractual relationship with the insurer and full rights to file and manage claims. Co-owners such as joint property owners and spouses both listed on the policy may each initiate a claim, though both typically must sign settlement checks.

Additional Claimants

  • Mortgage lender (loss payee) — the bank or lender with a financial interest in the property is named on the policy as mortgagee, must endorse insurance settlement checks, and protects their collateral interest
  • Property managers (with authority) — if granted power of attorney, may act on behalf of property owners for rental or investment properties with documented authorization
  • Estate representatives — executors or administrators handling claims for a deceased owner, requiring legal documentation
  • HOA or condo association — for common area or shared roof elements when a master policy covers certain damage, acting on behalf of unit owners separately from individual unit owner claims

Claimant Rights

Right to Fair Treatment

As a claimant, you are entitled to prompt acknowledgement of your claim — typically within 15–30 days by state law — along with assignment of a claim number and adjuster. You are entitled to a thorough investigation including professional inspection of all reported damage, fair assessment based on actual conditions, and consideration of all evidence you provide. You are entitled to good faith handling with honest evaluation of your claim, fair interpretation of policy language, and reasonable settlement offers without intentional delay or obstruction. You are entitled to clear communication in plain language with written documentation of determinations.

Right to Representation

You have the absolute right to bring representatives to adjuster inspections or claim discussions. Insurers cannot prohibit this. Your roofing contractor can attend adjuster inspections and provide technical expertise. A public adjuster — a licensed professional who works for you — can negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf for a fee of typically 5–15% of the settlement. An insurance attorney can provide legal representation for disputed claims and pursue bad faith remedies when warranted.

Right to Documentation

You are entitled to receive the adjuster’s report including damage assessment details, photographs taken during inspection, scope of work and estimates, and coverage determinations with rationale. You are entitled to all claim correspondence, policy provisions affecting your claim, and detailed settlement calculations including depreciation breakdowns and deductible applications.

Right to Appeal

If you disagree with claim decisions, you can pursue internal appeals by requesting reconsideration and submitting additional evidence. Many policies include an appraisal clause providing third-party binding resolution of valuation disputes. You can file complaints with the Colorado Division of Insurance to request investigation of unfair practices. Legal action — hiring an attorney for bad faith or breach of contract — is available when other remedies fail. Colorado’s bad faith statutes provide double damages and attorney fee recovery when carriers act unreasonably.

Claimant Responsibilities

Duty to Report Promptly

Most policies require prompt or immediate notification — specific timeframes vary but often range from 60 days to one year. Report damage quickly to connect it to the specific event, prevent additional damage, show good faith compliance, and preserve evidence while fresh. Waiting months after discovering damage makes it harder to prove when damage occurred and may violate policy requirements.

Duty to Mitigate Further Damage

Take reasonable steps to prevent additional loss — tarp obvious leaks or openings, move valuables away from leak areas, arrange emergency repairs if necessary. What is required is what a prudent person would do: temporary measures proportionate to preventing further loss. What is not required is dangerous repairs, expensive permanent repairs before the adjuster sees damage, or anything beyond common sense protection. Document mitigation efforts with photographs and receipts and submit mitigation costs for reimbursement.

Duty to Cooperate

Allow the adjuster to inspect your property, provide access to all damaged areas, answer questions truthfully and completely, submit requested documentation including contractor estimates and maintenance records, and maintain communication by responding to adjuster inquiries and keeping contact information current.

Duty of Honesty

Provide an accurate description of damage, a truthful account of when and how damage occurred, disclosure of pre-existing conditions, and correct information on claim forms. Do not exaggerate damage, claim pre-existing damage as new, inflate costs, or submit false documentation. Consequences of dishonesty include claim denial, policy cancellation, potential criminal charges, and difficulty obtaining future insurance. If you made an honest mistake, correct it immediately — most insurers understand good faith errors.

Common Claimant Challenges

Disputed Coverage

Common coverage disputes include cosmetic vs. functional damage determinations, pre-existing condition arguments, insufficient damage claims, and exclusion interpretations. Address disputes by requesting written explanations with policy citations, gathering professional contractor opinions, documenting functional impacts of damage, and filing a formal appeal when warranted.

Undervalued Settlements

Signs of undervaluation include a settlement significantly below contractor estimates, missing damage components in scope, unrealistic material or labor costs, excessive depreciation applied, and ignored collateral damage. Steps to take: get detailed written estimates from contractors, compare line by line with the adjuster’s estimate, identify specific discrepancies, request a supplement for missed items, and consider a public adjuster for significant gaps.

Communication Breakdowns

When the insurer is unresponsive, document all communication attempts with dates and names, escalate to the adjuster’s supervisor, send certified letters when necessary, and file a complaint with the Colorado Division of Insurance if delays continue without explanation.

Settlement Check Issues

Mortgage company complications are common — the lender must endorse the check and may hold funds until repairs are complete. Contact your mortgage company immediately when the claim is filed to understand their release process. Review settlement breakdowns carefully before accepting. Request corrections in writing with calculations if amounts are incorrect.

Multiple Claimants and Interests

Joint Owners

When multiple people own the property, all owners typically must agree to the settlement and checks usually require all signatures. Disputes between owners can complicate claims. Best practice: communicate with co-owners throughout the process, agree on contractor selection together, and coordinate on settlement acceptance.

Mortgage Company Involvement

Insurance checks are typically issued to you and your mortgage company jointly. The lender must endorse the check before you can deposit it and may hold funds in escrow, releasing them in stages as work progresses. This can add 1–4 weeks to the payment timeline — start communication with your lender early and plan for this delay in repair scheduling.

Rental or Investment Properties

Non-owner occupied properties may have a different policy type — landlord or investment property — with different coverage than a homeowner’s policy. Loss of rental income coverage may apply. The property owner typically files the claim, and tenant involvement depends on whether the tenant caused the damage. Tenants should have their own separate insurance for their personal belongings.

Claimant Mistakes to Avoid

Accepting the First Offer Too Quickly

Initial offers are often conservative, may miss hidden or collateral damage, and are difficult to reopen after settlement. Take time to review thoroughly, get your contractor’s opinion on the settlement offer, and understand you can negotiate before accepting.

Not Documenting Thoroughly

Without proper evidence, adjusters may dispute damage extent or attribute it to normal wear. Take extensive photos and videos, document everything in writing, keep copies of all correspondence, and create a timeline of events and actions. Relying solely on the adjuster’s photos is not sufficient.

Making Permanent Repairs Before Settlement

Fixing damage before the adjuster inspects prevents them from verifying the original condition and may void coverage for unverified damage. Make only temporary emergency repairs, wait for the adjuster inspection when possible, and save damaged materials as evidence.

Signing Documents Without Understanding

Signing releases or settlements without reading carefully may waive rights unknowingly and could prevent future supplements. Read everything before signing, ask questions about unclear provisions, and have your contractor or attorney review significant documents. Never feel pressured to sign immediately.

Working With Contractors as a Claimant

How Contractors Help Claimants

Contractors provide technical expertise identifying all damage components and explaining roofing issues to adjusters. They provide documentation assistance with detailed estimates, professional photography, and supplemental damage reports. They offer claims advocacy by attending adjuster inspections and identifying discrepancies between estimates. They guide homeowners through the claims process and help navigate recoverable depreciation.

Red Flags in Contractor Relationships

  • Offering to waive or absorb your deductible — this is illegal in Colorado and a sign of fraud
  • Promising to guarantee claim approval — only the insurance company decides
  • Pressuring you to sign before settlement
  • Wanting you to assign insurance proceeds directly to them without a proper AOB review
  • Claiming to be a public adjuster without a license
  • No local address or established presence — signs of a storm chaser or fly-by-night roofer

Claimant’s Claim Timeline

Week 1: Discover damage, report to insurer, receive claim number and adjuster assignment, schedule inspection, begin documenting damage.

Weeks 2–3: Adjuster inspects property with you and your contractor present, adjuster prepares report and estimate, initial determination made.

Weeks 3–4: Receive settlement offer, compare with contractor estimates, request supplements if needed, negotiate discrepancies.

Weeks 4–6: Accept final offer, receive initial ACV payment, sign necessary documents, select contractor and schedule work.

Weeks 6–12: Contractor completes work, address issues during construction, file supplements for newly discovered damage, document completion.

Weeks 12–14: Submit completion documentation, receive recoverable depreciation, obtain final releases, close out claim.

Timeline varies significantly based on claim complexity and whether disputes arise. Complex claims can take 6+ months.

Questions Claimants Should Ask

Questions for Your Insurance Company

  • What is my claim number and who is my assigned adjuster?
  • What is the expected timeline for my claim?
  • What documentation do you need from me?
  • Can I have my contractor present during inspections?
  • How will my settlement be calculated?
  • What is the appeals process if I disagree with determinations?
  • How and when will I receive payment?

Questions for Your Adjuster

  • What damage did you identify during inspection?
  • Is all reported damage included in your assessment?
  • How did you calculate depreciation?
  • What policy provisions apply to my claim?
  • Can you explain any exclusions being applied?
  • How do I submit supplements for additional damage?
  • When can I expect a written report?

Also see these glossary entries:

  • Claim – The formal request you file as a claimant
  • Adjuster – The insurance professional who evaluates your claim
  • Public Adjuster – Licensed professional who represents claimants in disputes
  • Settlement – The amount the insurer agrees to pay to resolve your claim
  • Insurance Deductible – The amount you as claimant pay before coverage applies
  • Supplemental Claim – Additional claim for damage discovered after the initial inspection
  • Appraisal Clause – Formal process to challenge claim valuations you disagree with
  • Bad Faith – When insurer conduct crosses into unreasonable territory under Colorado law
  • Letter of Representation – Formal notice that a professional is representing you in the claim
  • Claim Denial – When insurers refuse to pay valid claims and what to do about it

As the claimant, you have more rights and more leverage than most Colorado homeowners realize — and the outcome of your claim depends heavily on how well those rights are exercised. A free inspection gives you professional documentation and independent expertise to support your position at every stage of the process, from the initial adjuster visit through final settlement.

📞 (719) 210-8699
📧 gerald@winik.io

Schedule Your Free Roof Inspection

← View All Glossary Terms