Claim

What Is a Claim?

A claim is a formal request submitted to your insurance company asking for coverage and compensation for roof damage caused by a covered peril. When you file a claim, you’re invoking your insurance policy’s contractual obligation to pay for repairs or replacement of your damaged roof, up to your policy limits and subject to your deductible.

Filing a claim initiates a process where your insurer investigates the damage, determines coverage, calculates what they owe, and issues payment. Understanding how this process works helps ensure you receive fair compensation for legitimate damage.

← Back to Glossary

---

When to File a Roof Claim

Covered Events That Warrant Claims

Storm damage:

• Hail impact causing shingle bruising or punctures
• Wind damage (missing shingles, lifted materials, torn sections)
• Tornado or hurricane damage
• Lightning strikes causing fire or structural damage
• Heavy snow or ice causing collapse or structural stress

Sudden accidents:

• Fallen trees or large branches
• Fire or smoke damage from any sudden cause
• Aircraft, vehicle, or other object impact
• Vandalism or malicious damage
• Accidental damage during other work

Related damage:

• Ice dam formation causing water infiltration
• Water damage from covered roof failures
• Collateral interior damage from roof leaks
• Structural issues from covered events

When NOT to File a Claim

Consider not filing when:

Damage is below your deductible:

• Repairs cost less than what you’d pay out-of-pocket
• Filing doesn’t provide financial benefit
• Avoids claim history impact
• Saves claim for more significant damage

Example: $800 repair with $2,500 deductible = no insurance benefit

Normal wear and tear:

• Gradual aging and deterioration
• Predictable end-of-life failure
• Maintenance-related issues
• Pre-existing damage or conditions

Minor cosmetic damage:

• Purely aesthetic issues (especially with cosmetic exclusions)
• No functional impairment
• Unlikely to be approved
• May affect future insurability

Maintenance issues:

• Problems from neglected upkeep
• Poor installation or workmanship
• Code violations
• Preventable deterioration

---

Types of Roof Claims

First-Party Claims

What it is: Claims you file with your own insurance company for damage to your property.

Characteristics:

• Most common type of roof claim
• Based on your homeowner’s policy
• Subject to your coverage limits and deductible
• You are the claimant
• Direct relationship with your insurer

Examples:

• Hail damages your roof
• Wind tears off shingles
• Lightning strikes your home
• Tree falls on your roof during a storm

Third-Party Claims

What it is: Claims filed against someone else’s insurance for damage they caused to your property.

Characteristics:

• You’re claiming against another party’s liability coverage
• No deductible on your end
• May take longer to resolve
• Requires proving liability
• Different claim process

Examples:

• Neighbor’s tree falls on your roof due to their negligence
• Contractor damages your roof during work
• Roofer’s work fails and causes damage
• Delivery truck damages your property

Supplemental Claims

What it is: Additional claim filed after the initial claim when more damage is discovered.

Characteristics:

• Part of original claim, not separate incident
• Common during repair process
• Same date of loss and deductible
• Requires documentation of newly found damage
• Must show connection to original event

Examples:

• Tear-off reveals hidden decking damage
• Water damage worse than initially assessed
• Structural issues discovered during repairs
• Additional rooms affected by leaks

Reopened Claims

What it is: Previously settled claim reopened due to ongoing issues or new discoveries related to original damage.

Characteristics:

• More difficult than supplements
• Time limits often apply
• Must prove connection to original loss
• May require additional evidence
• Not always successful

Examples:

• Leak persists after initial repairs
• Damage worsens from inadequate original repairs
• Previously missed damage discovered
• Repairs didn’t address underlying problem

---

The Claim Filing Process

Step 1: Assess and Document the Damage

Before contacting your insurer:

Immediate documentation:

• Take extensive photos and videos from multiple angles
• Capture wide shots showing damage extent
• Close-ups of specific damage areas
• Interior damage (water stains, ceiling issues)
• Damaged property contents
• Date/time stamp all documentation

Safety first:

• Don’t access dangerous areas
• Stay off damaged roofs
• Avoid compromised structures
• Call professionals for hazardous situations

Emergency protection:

• Make temporary repairs to prevent further damage
• Tarp obvious openings
• Place buckets under active leaks
• Move valuables away from damage
• Document before and after temporary repairs

Gather information:

• Note date and time of damage-causing event
• Collect weather reports or news coverage
• List all damaged areas
• Prepare description of what happened

Step 2: Review Your Insurance Policy

Before filing, understand:

Your coverage:

• Declaration page details (Coverage A amount, deductible)
• Coverage type (RCV vs. ACV)
• Special endorsements or limitations
• Exclusions that might apply

Policy requirements:

• Claim filing deadlines
• Notification requirements
• Your responsibilities as a policyholder
• Required documentation

Contact information:

• Agent phone number and email
• Insurance company claims hotline
• Policy number for reference
• Any 24/7 emergency contact numbers

Step 3: Contact Your Insurance Company

Initiate the claim:

How to file:

• Call your agent or company’s claims hotline
• Some insurers offer online claim filing
• Mobile apps for claim submission
• Written notice (less common but acceptable)

Information you’ll provide:

• Policy number
• Date and time of damage
• Description of what happened
• Type and extent of damage
• Your contact information
• Whether temporary repairs are needed

What to expect:

• Claim number assigned
• Adjuster assigned to your case
• Inspection scheduled
• Timeline for next steps
• Initial guidance on process

Document the filing:

• Note claim number immediately
• Record date and time of filing
• Note representative’s name
• Save confirmation (email, reference number)

Step 4: Prepare for Adjuster Inspection

Before the adjuster arrives:

Schedule considerations:

• Be present if possible
• Allow adequate time (typically 1-2 hours)
• Have contractor present if hired
• Ensure access to all damaged areas
• Don’t make permanent repairs yet

Prepare documentation:

• Your photos and videos
• Contractor estimates (if obtained)
• Maintenance records
• Previous inspection reports
• List of all damage points

Create a checklist:

• All areas you want adjuster to inspect
• Specific damage points to highlight
• Questions you want answered
• Concerns about coverage

Step 5: The Adjuster Inspection

During the inspection:

Point out all damage:

• Primary roof damage
• Collateral interior damage
• Exterior related damage (gutters, siding, fascia)
• Any safety concerns
• Previous repairs or known issues

Ask questions:

• What damage is the adjuster documenting?
• What coverage applies?
• How will payment be calculated?
• What’s the timeline for decision?
• How to submit additional information?

Document the inspection:

• Take notes on what adjuster examines
• Photograph areas adjuster inspects
• Note adjuster’s comments and observations
• Get adjuster’s contact information
• Understand next steps

Have contractor present:

• Identify technical issues
• Explain functional impacts
• Point out hidden damage concerns
• Provide professional perspective
• Document on their behalf

Step 6: Review the Settlement Offer

After adjuster completes assessment:

What you’ll receive:

• Written estimate of damages
• Explanation of coverage determination
• Payment calculation breakdown
• Instructions for next steps
• Timeline for payment

Review carefully:

• Compare to contractor estimates line-by-line
• Verify all damage is included
• Check depreciation calculations
• Confirm deductible is correct
• Understand payment structure (ACV initial, RCV after completion)

Common discrepancies:

• Missing damage components
• Underestimated quantities
• Low material or labor costs
• Excessive depreciation
• Scope differences

Step 7: Negotiate if Needed

If settlement seems inadequate:

Gather additional evidence:

• Detailed contractor estimates
• Professional assessments
• Manufacturer specifications
• Industry standard pricing
• Photos of missed damage

Request a supplement:

• Itemize discrepancies
• Provide supporting documentation
• Request specific line-item adjustments
• Reference policy provisions

Communicate in writing:

• Email or letter documenting concerns
• Specific references to estimate line items
• Professional tone, factual basis
• Request written response

Escalate if necessary:

• Request supervisor review
• Consider public adjuster
• File formal appeal
• Contact state insurance department

Step 8: Accept Settlement and Complete Repairs

Once you agree to settlement:

Payment received:

• Initial check (ACV minus deductible)
• Typically within 5-10 business days
• May be joint check with mortgage company
• Verify amounts before depositing

Select contractor:

• Choose licensed, insured professional
• Verify credentials and references
• Get written contract
• Understand payment terms
• Clarify warranty coverage

Complete repairs:

• Follow contract timeline
• Monitor work quality
• Address issues promptly
• Document completion
• Obtain final inspection if required

Step 9: Collect Recoverable Depreciation

For RCV policies after repairs:

Submit final documentation:

• Paid-in-full invoices
• Completion certificate
• Final inspection sign-off (if required)
• Photos of completed work
• Warranty documentation

Receive final payment:

• Recoverable depreciation released
• Typically 2-3 weeks after submission
• Verify amount matches initial calculation
• Deposit and close claim

Timeline requirements:

• Usually 180-365 days to complete and submit
• Verify your specific policy deadline
• Request extensions if needed
• Don’t miss deadline or forfeit payment

---

Claim Settlement Structures

Full Replacement Settlement

When it applies:

• Damage extensive enough to warrant full roof replacement
• Test squares meet damage thresholds
• Repair impractical or insufficient
• Matching issues require full replacement

What’s covered:

• Complete tear-off and disposal
• All roofing materials
• Labor and installation
• Code upgrades (if you have ordinance/law coverage)
• Related components (flashing, vents, etc.)

Example:

• 35-square roof completely replaced
• Replacement cost: $28,000
• Depreciation: $9,000
• Deductible: $2,500
• Initial payment: $16,500
• After completion: $9,000
• Total received: $25,500

Partial Repair Settlement

When it applies:

• Damage limited to specific sections
• Test squares below replacement threshold
• Repair feasible and sufficient
• Isolated damage area

What’s covered:

• Damaged section replacement
• Matching adjacent areas if necessary
• Pro-rated costs for partial work
• Disposal of damaged materials only

Challenges:

• Matching discontinued materials
• Warranty considerations
• Color/texture blending
• May require larger section than damage alone

Example:

• 8 squares damaged on 30-square roof
• Section replacement cost: $9,000
• Depreciation: $2,700
• Deductible: $2,500
• Initial payment: $3,800
• After completion: $2,700
• Total received: $6,500

Repair-in-Place Settlement

When it applies:

• Minor damage only
• Individual shingle replacement sufficient
• No widespread concerns
• Temporary fix acceptable

What’s covered:

• Specific damaged shingles
• Minimal surrounding work
• Sealant or adhesive
• Basic labor costs

Limitations:

• Often insufficient for significant damage
• May not address underlying issues
• Warranty implications
• Consider carefully before accepting

---

Claim Valuation Methods

Xactimate Estimating Software

Industry-standard tool:

What it is:

• Software used by most insurance adjusters
• Database of material and labor costs
• Regional pricing variations
• Standardized calculation methodology

How it works:

• Adjuster inputs damage details
• Software calculates costs based on database
• Applies local multipliers
• Generates line-item estimate

Pros:

• Consistent methodology
• Regularly updated pricing
• Widely accepted
• Detailed breakdowns

Cons:

• May not reflect actual market costs
• Generic pricing doesn’t account for all variables
• Contractor may have difficulty matching rates
• Homeowner can’t access software directly

Actual Cost Estimates

Contractor-provided pricing:

What it is:

• Detailed estimates from roofing contractors
• Based on actual supplier costs
• Real-world labor rates
• Market-specific pricing

How contractors estimate:

• Measure roof dimensions
• Calculate material quantities
• Apply current material costs
• Include actual labor rates
• Add overhead and profit

Value for claims:

• Shows real market pricing
• Supports settlement negotiations
• Identifies Xactimate discrepancies
• Provides leverage in disputes

Reconciling Differences

When estimates don’t match:

Common reasons:

• Material quality differences
• Labor rate variations
• Included vs. excluded items
• Overhead and profit percentages
• Scope interpretation differences

How to address:

• Line-by-line comparison
• Identify specific discrepancies
• Provide supporting documentation
• Request adjuster explanation
• Negotiate based on facts

---

Common Claim Outcomes

Full Approval

Best case scenario:

What happens:

• Damage confirmed as covered
• Settlement adequate for repairs
• Few or no disputes
• Smooth payment and completion

Timeline:

• Claim filed to approval: 2-4 weeks
• Payment received: 1-2 weeks after approval
• Repairs completed: 1-4 weeks
• Final payment: 2-3 weeks after completion
• Total: 6-12 weeks typically

Partial Approval

Mixed outcome:

What happens:

• Some damage covered, some excluded
• Settlement covers portion of repairs
• Requires negotiation or acceptance
• May need to pay out-of-pocket for excluded items

Common scenarios:

• Functional damage covered, cosmetic excluded
• New damage covered, pre-existing excluded
• Primary damage covered, some collateral excluded
• Storm damage covered, maintenance issues excluded

Your options:

• Accept partial settlement
• Appeal excluded portions
• Provide additional evidence
• Proceed with covered repairs only

Denial

Claim rejected:

Common reasons:

• Damage not from covered peril
• Exclusion applies (wear and tear, maintenance)
• Insufficient damage (doesn’t meet thresholds)
• Pre-existing condition argument
• Policy lapse or coverage gap

Your options:

• Request detailed written denial with policy citations
• Gather additional evidence
• File formal appeal
• Hire public adjuster
• Consult attorney
• Contact state insurance department

Underpayment

Settlement insufficient:

Signs:

• Payment well below contractor estimates
• Missing damage components
• Unrealistic pricing
• Excessive depreciation
• Inadequate scope

Your recourse:

• Request supplement
• Provide competing estimates
• Document additional damage
• Negotiate line items
• Escalate to management
• Consider appraisal clause or legal action

---

Multiple Claims Considerations

Impact on Insurance

Filing multiple claims:

Rate impacts:

• Single claim: Minimal to moderate impact
• Multiple claims (2-3 in 3-5 years): Significant increases
• Excessive claims (4+ in 3-7 years): Major increases or non-renewal
• Catastrophic events treated differently

Insurability concerns:

• CLUE report tracks all claims
• Future insurers review claim history
• Multiple claims reduce options
• May be forced into high-risk pools
• Premiums substantially higher

Strategic considerations:

• File only necessary claims
• Consider paying small claims out-of-pocket
• Weigh claim benefit vs. future cost
• Separate covered events properly

Same Roof, Multiple Events

When storms occur sequentially:

Proper approach:

• File separate claims for separate events
• Document which damage from which event
• Establish distinct dates of loss
• Separate deductibles may apply

Example:

• June hail damages 30% of roof
• August wind damages different sections
• File two claims with separate dates of loss
• Each has own deductible
• Must prove damage is distinct

Challenges:

• Difficult to separate overlapping damage
• Adjuster may argue it’s one event
• Documentation critical
• May require expert opinion

---

Claim Red Flags and Fraud

Legitimate vs. Fraudulent Claims

Honest claims include:

• Accurate damage descriptions
• Truthful timelines
• Real damage from covered events
• Proper documentation
• Good faith representations

Fraudulent claims involve:

• Exaggerating damage extent
• Claiming pre-existing damage as new
• Inflating costs intentionally
• False documentation
• Misrepresenting when/how damage occurred

Contractor-Related Fraud

Warning signs:

Unethical practices:

• Offering to “waive” your deductible (rebating—illegal in most states)
• Creating or exaggerating damage
• Inflating estimates for insurance
• Kickbacks for choosing their company
• Pressure to assign benefits

Why it’s problematic:

• Illegal and voids coverage
• Can result in claim denial
• May face criminal charges
• Civil liability
• Policy cancellation
• Difficulty obtaining future insurance

Protect yourself:

• Never sign agreements to waive deductible
• Don’t let contractors speak for you without supervision
• Review all documents before signing
• Report unethical behavior
• Choose reputable, licensed contractors

---

Claim Disputes and Appeals

Internal Appeals

If you disagree with claim determination:

Steps to appeal:

1. Request written denial/determination with policy citations
2. Gather supporting evidence (estimates, photos, expert opinions)
3. Submit formal appeal in writing
4. Reference specific policy provisions supporting your position
5. Request manager or supervisor review
6. Follow company’s appeals timeline and procedures

Supporting documentation:

• Professional contractor assessments
• Engineer reports (for structural disputes)
• Manufacturer technical bulletins
• Industry standards and guidelines
• Additional photographic evidence
• Weather data supporting your position

Appraisal Clause

Alternative dispute resolution:

What it is:

• Policy provision for resolving valuation disputes
• Each party selects an appraiser
• Appraisers select an umpire
• Majority decision on value is binding

When to use:

• Disputes over amount of loss (not coverage)
• Settlement amount disagreements
• Scope of work differences
• Pricing disputes

Limitations:

• Doesn’t resolve coverage disputes
• Each party pays own appraiser
• Umpire cost shared
• Binding decision (limited appeal)

Legal Action

Last resort:

When to consider:

• Significant financial impact
• Clear policy violation by insurer
• Bad faith indicators
• All other remedies exhausted
• Potential for bad faith damages

Types of legal claims:

• Breach of contract
• Bad faith (unreasonable claim handling)
• Unfair claims practices
• Statutory violations

Before filing lawsuit:

• Consult attorney experienced in insurance law
• Understand costs vs. potential recovery
• Consider settlement negotiations
• Review policy’s arbitration clauses
• Check state-specific requirements

---

Questions to Ask When Filing a Claim

Questions for Your Insurer

1. What is my claim number and assigned adjuster’s contact information?
2. What is the expected timeline for each step of the process?
3. What documentation do you need from me?
4. Will I receive written confirmation of my claim filing?
5. How will the adjuster inspection be scheduled?
6. What happens if I disagree with the adjuster’s assessment?
7. How and when will payment be issued?
8. What are my responsibilities during this process?

Questions for Your Adjuster

1. What damage are you documenting?
2. Is all the damage I reported included in your assessment?
3. What coverage applies to my specific situation?
4. How are you calculating depreciation?
5. What is the timeline for receiving your report?
6. How do I submit additional information or evidence?
7. Can I get a copy of your estimate and photos?
8. What are the next steps after your inspection?

Questions for Your Contractor

1. Does the insurance estimate cover all necessary repairs?
2. What’s missing or undervalued in the adjuster’s scope?
3. Can you attend the adjuster inspection?
4. Will you help prepare supplement requests if needed?
5. What’s your process for working with insurance claims?
6. How do payments work with insurance proceeds?
7. What warranties do you provide?
8. What happens if additional damage is discovered during repairs?

---

Related Roofing Terms

• Claimant: The person (you) filing the claim
• Adjuster: Insurance professional who evaluates your claim
• Coverage: The insurance protection your claim is based on
• Date of Loss: When the damage occurred that prompted your claim
• Deductible: Amount you pay before insurance coverage applies
• Depreciation: Reduction in value affecting claim settlement
• Supplement: Additional claim for damage discovered after initial filing
• Settlement: Final amount insurer agrees to pay
• Collateral Damage: Secondary damage covered under same claim

---

Professional Claim Support

Filing and managing a roof insurance claim involves numerous steps, complex documentation, and careful negotiation. As professional roof consultants, we help homeowners throughout the entire claim process:

• Assess and document damage before filing
• Advise on whether filing a claim makes financial sense
• Attend adjuster inspections to ensure thorough assessment
• Review settlement offers for adequacy
• Identify undervalued or missing components
• Prepare and submit supplement requests
• Negotiate with adjusters on technical issues
• Advocate for fair settlements
• Guide you through every step of the process

Need help with a roof insurance claim? Contact us today for a free consultation. We’ll assess your damage, explain your options, and provide expert support throughout the entire claims process to ensure you receive the full compensation you deserve.